By Laura Taylor
As much as we love the thrill of tasting wines from barrel and sniffing out future stars for your cellar, we get a real buzz from tasting mature wines that we have helped our customers to source and store over the years. With this in mind, Andrew, Nicola and I were thrilled to be invited to a blind tasting of burgundies over dinner with an incredibly generous friend of Private Cellar. Not even a train strike was going to deter us – we were determined to get there by car, by bus … on foot if necessary.
The bar was set high from the start with a glass of an old friend awaiting us: Salon 1996 – rich with creamy hazelnuts on the palate, a touch of honey but with a beautiful citrus zip behind, reminding us that whilst it can be drunk young, Salon is also a brilliant keeper. This was contrasted with a taste of Bollinger PN TX 2017, the penultimate release from the Bollinger PN Series – a brilliant wine in its own right but really showing its youth against the Le Mesnil heavyweight.
Supper was accompanied by lively conversation between keen wine enthusiasts and four flights of wines. Two whites were up first – a superbly fresh, unmistakably a great quality wine with the hallmarks of Domaine Leflaive … but which one? We were all hedging for one of the 1er Cru Pulignys and were amazed to discover that it was a 2015 Meursault 1er Cru Sous Le Dos d’Ane. This is a wine that is ageing with great style. Alongside that was a broader white, slightly tinged by oxidation which I had as Meursault but it was a Corton Charlemagne GC from Bonneau du Martray. Who said this blind tasting game is easy? Round one to Domaine Leflaive.
Next followed a flight of three whites, one of which was showing quite strangely, Chassagne Montrachet Domaine Michel Niellon 2018, so our host called in a second bottle – the 2017 vintage – which was better but still not quite right. I wonder if it was as much to do with the fact that we were tasting out of a different, much smaller glass as anything else but the wines were both more advanced than we would have expected and we advise bringing your drinking dates forward on these wines if you haven’t drunk them already. The other two wines in the flight were right up my street. The first was my favourite wine of all time, Nuits St Georges Blanc 1er Cru Clos de l’Arlot; the 2017 is still so appley and fresh that there were some calls for grand cru Chablis and there is no hurry to drink this one up. This was contrasted by a wine of pure class, a broad, creamy yet elegant and bright Bâtard Montrachet from Fontaine Gagnard’s 2015 vintage. What a wine! Allocations of this are minuscule in the UK, so our host was incredibly generous to share this rare bottle with us.
As with the whites, the red flights were served as a pair, followed by a trio and the quality was outstanding from the first sip. Our host had lined up a 2003 Echézeaux from Domaine de la Romanée-Conti alongside a 2004 Musigny Grand Cru from Domaine Comte Georges de Vogüé which split the crowd as to which was their favourite. I was in the Echézeaux camp for its clear pedigree and layers of intense black fruit with just a hint of evolution but there were strong calls for the incredibly elegant Musigny too. Really, we were splitting hairs.
The final red flight was made up of Domaine Marquis d’Angerville’s monopole Volnay Clos des Ducs 2009 (mellowing now, with silky black fruit and a floral hint), 2008 Clos de Tart Grand Cru (another monopole showing beautifully with savoury notes behind the brambly fruit and plenty of life ahead of it) and a smoky and still quite structured 2012 Clos de Vougeot Grand Cru from Domaine Arnoux-Lachaux – a wine which has increased fivefold in value since release. The Clos de Tart was my favourite here (again, splitting hairs) and there were equal votes for the Volnay, which showed a lot of class.
As if this wasn’t enough, one of the guests was generous enough to share a bottle of 1980 Château d’Yquem with us. It would be an understatement to say that 1980 wasn’t a great year but it was incredibly generous given that it was a birth year bottle and the adage of ‘buy from a great producer in a poor year’ usually stands any buyer in good stead. Finally, there was a cheeky, luscious and candied Château Climens 2003 to send us on our way.
What an immense treat to taste wines that are in their prime, ready to drink but offering so much more – wines that are layered and mature, savoury and intense, some showing more zip and youth than their vintage might suggest, others galloping along a little faster than we would have liked. Do have a look at our Fine Wine list which is well-stocked with mature bottles from Burgundy and beyond. If you’re feeling very flash, there are magnums from Domaine de la Romanée-Conti and Domaine Jacques-Frédéric Mugnier. I’ve searched for my favourite Nuits St Georges Blanc from Domaine de l’Arlot to no avail but there are some of their truly delicious reds on the list and you’ll find wines from almost all of the producers listed above.
If you’d like to start collecting Burgundy, call us and have a chat with one of our friendly and knowledgeable sales team on 01353 977 995. You may also consider our Ways to Save with Private Cellar, so you’re ready to jump on any allocations when they come out.
