By Nick Clarke
A very special tasting of 20 wines from one of Burgundy’s most sought-after appellations. See which wines came out top in each flight, with some interesting over-performers.
Last week, I was lucky enough to attend a very special tasting of Echézeaux 2018s at Browns Hotel. Two wine collectors wanted to taste the wines along with their friends and colleagues and arranged for Mary Margaret McCamic MW from Napa Valley to join us and introduce the wines over Zoom. Mary Margaret had recently returned from Burgundy where she’d had a dinner with one of the hosts to discuss the format of the evening.
It was decided that 20 of the top Echézeaux 2018s (of around 80 made in total) would be provided from the hosts’ cellars or sourced especially (including one by Private Cellar) for the evening and served, alongside a superb dinner, in four flights of five. The theme was nominally ‘Girls vs Boys’, in reference to the winemakers. The wines weren’t served blind though and we knew the prices of each bottle, so our challenge was to find value for money.
Flight 1:
- Henri Boillot
- Forey
- Faiveley
- Lamarche
- Anne Gros
Anne Gros was the winner here, with an elegant, grown-up wine, though both Boillot and Faiveley performed admirably, and well above their price bracket. Forey was an interesting one, a Domaine few knew much about, with a funky, different approach to Echézeaux. Maybe one to look out for in future.
Flight 2:
- Rouget
- Lucien Le Moine
- Claire Naudin
- Georges Noëllat (actually a Grands Echézeaux as the host wanted Noëllat to outperform!)
- A F Gros
Claire Naudin was the loose cannon here with few again knowing much about her wines, and she makes a wild, fun, maybe slightly overdone style. Noëllat’s GE was impressive, but the winner and a split in the room were between the excellent AF Gros and maybe a slightly too forward Rouget. Really enjoyable now, one of the tasters (who has been collecting Jayer/Rouget for 30 years) did wonder whether the previous depth of wine was there.
Flight 3:
- Jacques Prieur
- Grivot
- Méo-Camuzet
- Dujac
- Mugneret-Gibourg
The battle of the big, burly styles of wine was won in the end by a serious Echézeaux from Dujac over a delicious Grivot (does Grivot ever make a bad wine?) and a big, dry Méo-Camuzet that did finally open up towards the end. Mugneret-Gibourg for the girls made for light relief, being by far the most expressive wine of the flight, though did that make the sister’s wine better than Dujac? I personally, very slightly, thought that Dujac had made the better wine but Mugneret-Gibourg the better wine for right now.
Flight 4:
- Comte Liger-Belair
- Romanée-Conti
- Arnoux-Lachaux
- Tremblay
- Bizot
And then we came to the big players, the obvious question being how the up and coming (and extremely expensive wines – the Bizot had cost €12,000 alone) compared to the older hands. The answer was, pretty well! It was generally agreed that Comte had made the top wine, a very special, elegant wine, while to my mind a slightly light Tremblay took joint second place with a heavier and less elegant DRC. Bizot’s Echézeaux was a bit funky (though that is the style he makes), but in the main extremely elegant and, while not the top wine, ran it close, with to my mind a lumpy Arnoux-Lachaux bringing up the rear. However, these are some of the most special wines on the planet and it was noticeable that everyone’s glasses were empty after the flight.
Girls vs Boys: an honourable draw.
An amazing evening, thanks so much to the two collectors.