By Laura Taylor
The importance of tasting in situ, why we don’t quote scores and why experience in tasting before the blockbuster Bordeaux years of 2009 and 2010 really counts. Find out more about our approach to buying wines en primeur here…
Our buying director, Nicola Arcedeckne-Butler MW, is one of only 419 Masters of Wine in the world. She has been tasting and buying Bordeaux primeurs since 1992 and her experience really counts in every vintage.

Thanks to the vagaries of a maritime climate, some Bordeaux vintages are easier to taste from barrel than others. Many of today’s wine buyers were lucky enough to start tasting primeurs in the blockbuster years of 2009 and 2010 when we encountered wines with super ripe fruit, high alcohol and ripe tannins but, as we know, not all vintages are born equal.
And this is where Nicola’s experience comes to the fore.
When we taste barrel samples of Bordeaux, our task is to assess juvenile wines in their most naked stage and cast our palates and opinions forward to when they will be ready to drink. Nicola’s encyclopaedic memory – enhanced by a serried row of Bordeaux primeur notebooks by her desk – allows her to taste a wine and cast her mind back to previous vintages, remembering how they developed in bottle, thereby enabling her to assess quality, value and longevity when tasting from barrel. At this stage, prices have not been revealed, so it is purely a qualitative exercise and it’s essential to take detailed notes on the balance of fruit, tannins, acidity, the typicity of the wine and the nuances of depth and concentration. The unedited version of her notes that she sent me on the last day of her trip contained 18,000 words, almost twice the length of a Master of Wine research paper!
The tastings take place during the Union des Grands Crus (UGC) en primeur week in Bordeaux, in the Spring following the harvest, when buyers and journalists descend on the châteaux to taste, swirl and spit out hundreds of wines a day. It’s a frenetic week of teeth-staining work as we hurtle from tasting to tasting, always trying to keep one step ahead of a packed itinerary. Purple teeth is not a glamorous look, by the way, and its harder work than it sounds to the uninitiated!
This year Nicola decided to take a week in Bordeaux before the rest of the Trade descended to spend time tasting and talking with the châteaux owners – you can see her vintage report here. This allowed her to really get under the skin of a vintage which, on paper, was difficult due to weather conditions but the wine in the glass told another story. Some commentators were quick to judge the vintage on the weather alone, before even tasting, but this time spent in situ really gave Nicola an understanding of the wines, and she was pleased to discover delicious medium to long-term clarets, prettily fruited, fresh and immediate, direct and definitely cellar-worthy.
Andrew and I were delighted to hear this as we followed up with three days during the UGC week to get a feel for the wines and visit some additional properties, including our friends the Moueix’s, the Krajewski family at Châteaux Clos Cantenac and Séraphine and Paulin and Isabelle Calvet at Château Picque Caillou.
A quick note on scores…
You will notice that we don’t score wines at Private Cellar, and we rarely quote scores from other sources in our offers. This is because, whilst we respect the great wine writers, we primarily respect Nicola’s experience and integrity. We have all tried to get a wine past her for emotional reasons but she is very clear with us that if she doesn’t believe it has a great price:quality ratio, or the structure and quality to be sold with Private Cellar’s name attached to it, it won’t make the list. We want to be talking to you in 10, 20, 30 years’ time as you enjoy wines that we have sold to you now, on our recommendation. I can’t tell you how much enjoyment we get from hearing how well a Private Cellar wine, carefully laid down, has gone down at a wedding, shoot party or significant birthday. And that’s why we trust our buyer’s palate, experience and sixth sense when it comes to buying fine wine. We look forward to sharing her discoveries with you.
Our top tips for Bordeaux en primeur 2021
Great Value Drinkers
- Ch Chantalouette, Pomerol 2021 @ £170 /12 in bond
- Marquis de Calon Ségur, St Estèphe 2021 @ £238 /12 in bond
- Ch Angludet, Margaux 2021 @ £138 /6 in bond
- Ch Puy Blanquet, Grand Cru St Emilion 2021 @ £240 /12 in bond
- Ch Picque Caillou, Pessac Léognan 2021 @ £169 /6 in bond
Dinner parties
- Clos Cantenac, Grand Cru St Emilion 2021 @ £325 /12 in bond
- Ch Brane Cantenac, 2ème Cru Classé Margaux 2021 @ £282 /6 in bond
- Ch Lagrange, Pomerol 2021 @ £250 /12 in bond
- Ch d’Issan, 3ème Cru Classé Margaux 2021 @ £503 /12 in bond
- La Croix Ducru Beaucaillou, St Julien 2021 @ £195 /6 in bond
Special occasions
- Ch Calon Ségur, 3ème Cru Classé St Estèphe 2021 @ £488 /6 in bond
- Ch Quintus, Grand Cru St Emilion 2021 @ £444 /6 in bond
- Ch Grand Puy Lacoste, 5ème Cru Classé Pauillac 2021 @ £600 /12 in bond
- Ch Beychevelle, 4ème Cru Classé St Julien 2021 @ £354 /6 in bond
- Ch La Gaffelière, 1er Grand Cru Classé St Emilion 2021 @ £288 /6 in bond
Splash out
- Ch Séraphine, Pomerol 2021 @ £575 /6 in bond
- Ch Bélair Monange, Grand Cru St Emilion 2021 @ £675 /6 in bond
- Ch Tertre Roteboeuf, Grand Cru St Emilion 2021 @ £790 /6 in bond
- Ch La Fleur Pétrus, Pomerol 2021 @ £910 /6 in bond
- Ch Haut Brion, 1er Cru Classé Pessac Léognan 2021 @ £2,550 /6 in bond
Find some of our Bordeaux 2021 offers here with comprehensive tasting notes by Nicola Arcedeckne-Butler MW:
- Great Value wines
- Ets Jean-Pierre Moueix
- The Moueix Grands Vins
- Clos Cantenac and Château Séraphine
- The wines of François Mitjavile
- The Durantou Collection
Read our full 2021 vintage report or watch our Master of Wine Nicola Arcedeckne-Butler MW’s chat with Edouard Moueix to discover more about the Bordeaux 2021 growing season, the market and what to drink from your cellar while your 2021s mature.
Note: Prices here are release prices in May/June 2022 and will change as time moves on, according to availability.